Movies like
Loved the vibe? Here are ten films that hit similar notes—with match scores, reasons to watch, and where to stream in the US.
People revisit Shelby Oaks for the same reason it broke through in 2025: clear stakes, memorable faces, and a mystery rhythm that doesn't stall in the middle. Chris Stuckmann keeps the ensemble pointed in one direction. The horror and mystery blend is the engine: it lets the film shift registers without feeling like two different movies stitched together.
Runtime 1h 31m · ★ 5.7
Mood
Streaming (US)
Era
Showing 10 of 10 picks
★ 7.4 · Crime · Horror · Mystery · 1h 52m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, Scream (1996) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
fuboTV
Paramount Plus Premium
Paramount Plus Essential
Paramount+ Amazon Channel
YouTube TV
Paramount+ Roku Premium Channel
Amazon Video(Rent)
Apple TV Store(Rent)
★ 6.6 · Horror · Mystery · 1h 41m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, It Follows (2015) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
Philo
MovieSphere+ Amazon ChannelAmazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)
Google Play Movies(Rent)
YouTube(Rent)
Fandango At Home(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)
★ 6.4 · Horror · Mystery · 1h 21m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, The Blair Witch Project (1999) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
HBO Max
HBO Max Amazon Channel
USA NetworkApple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)Apple TV Store(Buy)
★ 6.8 · Horror · Mystery · 1h 43m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, Barbarian (2022) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
HulufuboTVAmazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)
★ 6.7 · Horror · Mystery · 1h 51m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, Malignant (2021) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
Amazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)
Spectrum On Demand(Rent)
Plex(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)
★ 6.6 · Horror · Mystery · 1h 30m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, The Taking of Deborah Logan (2014) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
Amazon Prime Video
AMC Plus Apple TV Channel 
AMC+ Amazon Channel
AMC+Philo
Shudder
Shudder Amazon Channel
Screambox Amazon Channel
★ 6.3 · Horror · Mystery · 1h 43m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, Until Dawn (2025) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
NetflixAmazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)Plex(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)
★ 6.7 · Horror · Mystery · Thriller · 1h 39m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, Stir of Echoes (1999) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
PhiloAmazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)Apple TV Store(Buy)
★ 6.7 · Horror · Mystery · 1h 38m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, Oddity (2024) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Watch on
HuluAMC Plus Apple TV Channel AMC+ Amazon ChannelAMC+ShudderShudder Amazon Channel
Shudder Apple TV ChannelAmazon Video(Rent)
★ 6.8 · Horror · Mystery · Thriller · 2h 5m
Why you'll love it
If Shelby Oaks clicked for you, The Entity (1982) is a strong next stop: both trade in horror and mystery, with unease that lingers after the credits. Expect a different story, but a similar willingness to go big when the moment demands it.
Browse every "movies like" page on the site—including ones still waiting to be indexed.