Movies like
Loved the vibe? Here are ten films that hit similar notes—with match scores, reasons to watch, and where to stream in the US.
People revisit Thanksgiving for the same reason it broke through in 2023: clear stakes, memorable faces, and a mystery rhythm that doesn't stall in the middle. Eli Roth keeps the ensemble pointed in one direction. The horror and mystery blend is the engine: it lets the film shift registers without feeling like two different movies stitched together.
Runtime 1h 46m · ★ 6.5
Mood
Streaming (US)
Era
Showing 10 of 10 picks
★ 7.4 · Crime · Horror · Mystery · 1h 52m
Why you'll love it
The filmmakers behind Scream (1996) clearly understood what makes horror work — the same quality that keeps Thanksgiving rewatchable. Expect the same dark rhythm, executed with a fresh angle.
Watch on
fuboTV
Paramount Plus Premium
Paramount Plus Essential
Paramount+ Amazon Channel
YouTube TV
Paramount+ Roku Premium Channel
Amazon Video(Rent)
Apple TV Store(Rent)
★ 6.5 · Horror · Mystery · 2h
Why you'll love it
Scream 2 (1997) is the kind of film Thanksgiving fans discover and immediately send to their group chat. The horror overlap is real, but it's the dark emotional pull that seals the recommendation.
Watch on
fuboTVParamount Plus PremiumParamount Plus EssentialParamount+ Amazon ChannelYouTube TVParamount+ Roku Premium ChannelAmazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)
★ 7.0 · Horror · Mystery · Crime · 1h 38m
Why you'll love it
Black Christmas shares Thanksgiving's gift for horror — the 1974 film delivers mystery without overstaying its welcome. Consider it required viewing once you've finished rewatching your first pick.
Watch on
Amazon Prime Video
Peacock Premium
AMC+ Amazon Channel
Fandor
Philo
Shudder
Night Flight Plus
Shudder Amazon Channel
★ 6.3 · Horror · Mystery · Crime · 1h 44m
Why you'll love it
Much of what makes Thanksgiving compelling — the horror, the mystery — shows up in I Am Not a Serial Killer (2016) in a slightly different form. Both films understand that dark storytelling works best when it trusts the audience.
Watch on
AMC Plus Apple TV Channel AMC+ Amazon Channel
AMC+PhiloShudder
Sundance NowShudder Amazon Channel
Shudder Apple TV Channel
★ 6.3 · Horror · Mystery · 1h 28m
Why you'll love it
The horror energy of Thanksgiving is alive in Intruder (1989), filtered through a different story but the same emotional register. It earns its place on this list with a dark payoff that rivals the original pick.
Watch on
AMC+ Amazon ChannelPhiloShudderShudder Amazon Channel
Full Moon Amazon ChannelShudder Apple TV ChannelAmazon Video(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)
★ 7.0 · Horror · Thriller · Crime · 2h 3m
Why you'll love it
Scream VI (2023) operates in the same horror as Thanksgiving, but with its own distinct voice and pacing. The dark payoff will feel satisfyingly familiar without retreading the same ground.
Watch on
Paramount Plus PremiumParamount Plus EssentialParamount+ Roku Premium ChannelApple TV Store(Rent)
Google Play Movies(Rent)
YouTube(Rent)
Fandango At Home(Rent)
JustWatch TV(Rent)
★ 6.6 · Horror · Thriller · 1h 32m
Why you'll love it
Halloween II (1981) belongs to the same conversation as Thanksgiving — both anchor their horror in thriller emotion that doesn't let go. The dark undercurrent connects them more than any plot summary would suggest.
Watch on
Amazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)Apple TV Store(Buy)Google Play Movies(Buy)
★ 7.0 · Horror · Comedy · 1h 22m
Why you'll love it
If Thanksgiving's horror stayed with you, Trick 'r Treat (2007) delivers the same sensation through an entirely different story. The comedy through-line is the real common thread between them.
Watch on
Amazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)Apple TV Store(Buy)Google Play Movies(Buy)
★ 7.1 · Drama · Thriller · Mystery · 2h 8m
Why you'll love it
Where Thanksgiving excels in mystery, Murder on the Orient Express (1974) doubles down on drama to comparable effect. The tonal similarities run deep enough that watching both back-to-back feels intentional.
Watch on
fuboTVAmazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)
Spectrum On Demand(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)
★ 6.5 · Comedy · Horror · Science Fiction · 1h 26m
Why you'll love it
Critters (1986) is the natural next step after Thanksgiving: same horror DNA, different perspective. The dark streak and comedy elevate it well above a simple genre exercise.
Watch on
Amazon Video(Rent)Apple TV Store(Rent)Google Play Movies(Rent)YouTube(Rent)Fandango At Home(Rent)Amazon Video(Buy)Apple TV Store(Buy)Google Play Movies(Buy)Browse every "movies like" page on the site—including ones still waiting to be indexed.