What movies are similar to Totally Killer?

Start with films such as Trick 'r Treat, The Final Girls, Lisa Frankenstein, The Curse of Bridge Hollow. Each title on this page is chosen to mirror the vibe, themes, and style that make Totally Killer memorable, with short explanations to help you pick where to begin.

What should I watch if I liked Totally Killer?

Use the ranked list above: it highlights 10 close cousins—similar tension, character dynamics, and storytelling ambition—so you can queue something tonight without endless browsing.

Are there movies with the same vibe as Totally Killer?

Yes. The recommendations here lean into overlapping moods and motifs, not just shared genre labels, so you get films that “feel” related in pacing, tone, and emotional payoff.

What should I watch after Totally Killer?

Try Trick 'r Treat, The Final Girls, Lisa Frankenstein—each shares DNA with Totally Killer while changing the setting enough to feel fresh.

What genre is Totally Killer?

Totally Killer (2023) is best described as Horror, Comedy, Science Fiction. Stores and algorithms use different labels, but that mix is what fans actually recognize on a rewatch.

Is Totally Killer worth revisiting?

Viewer scores sit around 6.8/10 on TMDB—high enough that replays are common for people who like this horror lane.

Movies like

If Totally Killer Moved You, These Will Too

Where to Watch

Totally Killer (2023) works because totally Killer (2023) stuck because it commits to its horror premise without apologizing—viewers remember set pieces and momentum as much as plot. Nahnatchka Khan's control of tone keeps the ride coherent. The horror and comedy blend is the engine: it lets the film shift registers without feeling like two different movies stitched together. The concrete hook is when the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim,, and that gives this guide a clear center of gravity. For movies like Totally Killer, we prioritized horror, comedy, science fiction films that share horror, comedy, science fiction, divisive without flattening everything into one broad genre bucket. The best follow-ups preserve the pressure, rhythm, and point of view before they worry about matching plot mechanics. That is why the list below separates close tonal cousins from looser genre neighbors. These 10 recommendations are ordered to keep the Totally Killer feeling intact while still giving you different characters, stakes, and endings.

At a glance

Horror · Comedy · Science Fiction · 1h 44m · ★ 6.8

horrorcomedyscience fictiondivisive

Your 10 recommendations

Filter your results

Mood

Streaming (US)

Era

Showing 10 of 10 picks

96match
1.Trick 'r Treat (2007)
★ 7.0 · Horror · Fantasy · Comedy · 1h 22m
Why it fits
In Totally Killer, the spine is When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim,; Trick 'r Treat finds its spine in Four interwoven stories that occur on Halloween: an everyday high school principal has a secret life as a. horror, comedy explain.
Watch on
- Amazon Video(Rent)
- Apple TV Store(Rent)
- Google Play Movies(Rent)
- YouTube(Rent)
- Fandango At Home(Rent)
- Amazon Video(Buy)
- Apple TV Store(Buy)
- Google Play Movies(Buy)
We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page.
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
94match
2.The Final Girls (2015)
★ 6.4 · Comedy · Horror · 1h 31m
Why it fits
horror, comedy surface in both films, yet The Final Girls keeps the temperature a dark, uncompromising tone, not a tonal echo of Totally Killer. Compare A young woman grieving the loss of her mother, a famous scream queen from the 1980s, finds herself against When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35.
Watch on
- Amazon Video(Rent)
- Apple TV Store(Rent)
- Google Play Movies(Rent)
- YouTube(Rent)
- Fandango At Home(Rent)
- Amazon Video(Buy)
- Apple TV Store(Buy)
- Google Play Movies(Buy)
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
92match
3.Lisa Frankenstein (2024)
★ 6.3 · Horror · Comedy · Romance · 1h 42m
Why it fits
In 1989, a misunderstood teenager has a high school crush — who just happens to be a handsome is the sharpest reason to queue Lisa Frankenstein after Totally Killer: it refracts the same curiosity When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim,.
Watch on
- Amazon Video(Rent)
- Apple TV Store(Rent)
- Google Play Movies(Rent)
- YouTube(Rent)
- Fandango At Home(Rent)
- Spectrum On Demand(Rent)
- Amazon Video(Buy)
- Apple TV Store(Buy)
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
90match
4.The Curse of Bridge Hollow (2022)
★ 6.5 · Adventure · Comedy · Horror · 1h 30m
Why it fits
The Curse of Bridge Hollow is pitched a dark, uncompromising tone, which is the first thing you feel beside Totally Killer. horror, comedy, adventure still braid the two films, but The Curse of Bridge Hollow leans on A Halloween-hating dad reluctantly teams up with his teenage daughter when an evil spirit wreaks.
Watch on
- Netflix
- Netflix Standard with Ads
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
88match
5.Scary Movie (2000)
★ 6.4 · Comedy · 1h 28m
Why it fits
Character pressure in Scary Movie accumulates around A familiar-looking group of teenagers find themselves being stalked by a more-than-vaguely recognizable masked killer!, echoing how Totally Killer tightened the screws with When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim,. The through-line is comedy, not mirrored blocking.
Watch on
- Paramount Plus Premium
- Paramount Plus Essential
- Paramount+ Amazon Channel
- Amazon Video(Rent)
- Apple TV Store(Rent)
- Google Play Movies(Rent)
- YouTube(Rent)
- Fandango At Home(Rent)
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
86match
6.Terrifier (2018)
★ 6.3 · Horror · 1h 24m
Why it fits
Terrifier handles A maniacal clown named Art terrorizes three young women on Halloween night and everyone else who stands in with a Horror bias that Totally Killer did not foreground in its Horror read of When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim,. horror are the bridge.
Watch on
- Amazon Prime Video
- fuboTV
- Amazon Prime Video with Ads
- Amazon Video(Rent)
- Apple TV Store(Rent)
- Google Play Movies(Rent)
- YouTube(Rent)
- Fandango At Home(Rent)
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
84match
7.Fear Street: 1994 (2021)
★ 6.7 · Horror · Mystery · Drama · 1h 48m
Why it fits
A 2021 frame changes how After a series of brutal slayings, a teen and her friends take on an evil force that's plagued lands next to Totally Killer (2023) and its When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim,. horror, mystery survive.
Watch on
- Netflix
- Netflix Standard with Ads
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
82match
8.Halloween (2007)
★ 6.2 · Horror · 1h 50m
Why it fits
If When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim, is what locked you into Totally Killer, Halloween hands you The early years of young Michael Myers and the events leading up to his fateful Halloween night murder as the next jolt of.
Watch on
- MovieSphere+ Amazon Channel
- Amazon Video(Rent)
- Apple TV Store(Rent)
- Google Play Movies(Rent)
- YouTube(Rent)
- Fandango At Home(Rent)
- Plex(Rent)
- Amazon Video(Buy)
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
80match
9.Pearl (2022)
★ 7.2 · Horror · 1h 42m
Why it fits
Totally Killer and Pearl split at the plot: When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim, on one side, Trapped on her family’s isolated farm, Pearl must tend to her ailing father under the bitter and overbearing on the other. horror, thriller.
Watch on
- Amazon Video(Rent)
- Apple TV Store(Rent)
- Google Play Movies(Rent)
- YouTube(Rent)
- Fandango At Home(Rent)
- Spectrum On Demand(Rent)
- Amazon Video(Buy)
- Apple TV Store(Buy)
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later
78match
10.Fear Street: 1978 (2021)
★ 7.2 · Horror · Mystery · Drama · 1h 51m
Why it fits
The afterglow from Fear Street: 1978 is a dark, uncompromising tone: different residue than Totally Killer, even when horror, mystery read familiar. Trace the fork to When the infamous "Sweet Sixteen Killer" returns 35 years after his first murder spree to claim another victim, versus In 1978, two rival groups at Camp.
Watch on
- Netflix
- Netflix Standard with Ads
Search Prime Video Search Apple TV Compare streamers
+ Save for later

Why You'll Love These Movies

Across these recommendations, you will see recurring fingerprints from Totally Killer: horror, comedy, mystery, romance, plus a dark through-line that keeps scenes charged even when the plots diverge. The emotional appeal is consistent—films that ask for attention, then reward it with momentum, specificity, and a clear point of view. As a viewing experience, the list is built to feel like a guided night at the movies: enough variety to stay surprising, enough overlap to feel intentional, and pacing that respects how Totally Killer trained you to watch. If you want the same satisfaction you felt during Totally Killer—that mix of craft, stakes, and atmosphere—these picks are meant to land in the same neighborhood without repeating the same story.

FAQ

What movies are similar to Totally Killer?: Start with films such as Trick 'r Treat, The Final Girls, Lisa Frankenstein, The Curse of Bridge Hollow. Each title on this page is chosen to mirror the vibe, themes, and style that make Totally Killer memorable, with short explanations to help you pick where to begin.
What should I watch if I liked Totally Killer?: Use the ranked list above: it highlights 10 close cousins—similar tension, character dynamics, and storytelling ambition—so you can queue something tonight without endless browsing.
Are there movies with the same vibe as Totally Killer?: Yes. The recommendations here lean into overlapping moods and motifs, not just shared genre labels, so you get films that “feel” related in pacing, tone, and emotional payoff.
What should I watch after Totally Killer?: Try Trick 'r Treat, The Final Girls, Lisa Frankenstein—each shares DNA with Totally Killer while changing the setting enough to feel fresh.
What genre is Totally Killer?: Totally Killer (2023) is best described as Horror, Comedy, Science Fiction. Stores and algorithms use different labels, but that mix is what fans actually recognize on a rewatch.
Is Totally Killer worth revisiting?: Viewer scores sit around 6.8/10 on TMDB—high enough that replays are common for people who like this horror lane.

More movie guides

Browse the movie guides currently prioritized for search discovery and editorial expansion.

Hand-picked guides from this page's data—same editorial lane as Totally Killer.

MoviesLike Editorial TeamUpdated October 20, 2018

Cinematic essays Popular guides

If Totally Killer Moved You, These Will Too

Where to Watch

At a glance

Your 10 recommendations

Filter your results

1.Trick 'r Treat (2007)

2.The Final Girls (2015)

3.Lisa Frankenstein (2024)

4.The Curse of Bridge Hollow (2022)

5.Scary Movie (2000)

6.Terrifier (2018)

7.Fear Street: 1994 (2021)

8.Halloween (2007)

9.Pearl (2022)

10.Fear Street: 1978 (2021)

Why You'll Love These Movies

You Might Also Like

❓ FAQ

More movie guides

Related movies

FAQ